How to Run A/B Tests That Bring BIG Landing Page Results
July 16, 2014
A/B testing offers online marketers like you a host of potential benefits including a lower bounce rate, higher open rates and click-through rates in your email marketing and most importantly, more sales. When you do A/B testing, your customers and page visitors are giving you a gift; they are telling you what they like and don’t like about your online marketing. They are telling you how you can achieve greater and greater results.
The beauty of online marketing is that you can improve. It doesn’t matter if your results are “in the tank” or your campaigns are soaring sky high. You can improve them if you conduct A/B tests consistently and if you implement new changes accordingly.
If you aren’t doing A/B testing on a regular basis, if you aren’t harnessing its power to fine tune and improve the results in your online marketing, why not?
It’s Not That Hard!
Many in the online marketing world never test, perhaps because they fear it will be too time consuming or complicated. If you will be disciplined and smart about A/B testing, you’ll gain valuable insights through which you can enjoy more and more marketing success.
You can gain a major advantage over your competitors that don’t test. And guess what? It’s not that hard. And it doesn’t have to take that much time.
Almost every entry on this blog mentions A/B testing. We talk about advanced A/B testing capability as a feature of our Lander landing page platform. Indeed it is a very strong feature of our state of the art products, and it offers marketers like you a lot of potential benefits. More on that in a moment. Keep reading…
But what is A/B testing? And why should you care? Today we will answer these questions for you. We’ll give you some useful A/B testing tips. We’ll show some real life A/B testing success stories. We’ll be talking about A/B testing for landing pages mainly, but the concepts and ideas we discuss work for other parts of your online marketing engine including your email marketing, mobile marketing, and your website.
According to Wikipedia, in A/B testing
“….two versions (A and B) are compared, which are identical except for one variation that might impact a user’s behavior. Version A might be the currently used version (control), while Version B is modified in some respect (treatment). For instance, on an e-commerce website the purchase funnel is typically a good candidate for A/B testing, as even marginal improvements in drop-off rates can represent a significant gain in sales. Significant improvements can sometimes be seen through testing elements like copy text, layouts, images and colors.”
Marketers have tested and refined campaigns for many decades, but in the second decade of the 21st century, we have many more tools that can help us test and improve our online marketing campaigns easily and inexpensively (sometimes for free) than ever before.
A/B testing your landing pages can help you improve your conversion results in a big way, so by all means, test!
Here are some A/B testing best practices; Use them and you will enjoy greater results from your A/B testing and subsequent optimization pursuits while reducing the number of headaches you suffer.
Useful A/B Testing Tips
A/B testing, sometimes called split testing, involves comparing one page, the currently used control or “A” page, against the “B” page which has been modified in some way. Let’s say you change your written headline, your call to action button and switch images of your product all at the same time.
Your conversion rate compared to the control or A page goes down, way down. But since you changed three landing page elements all at the same time, you don’t know what led to your falling conversion rate. Was it a result of one change you made? Two changes? All three? And instead of being ahead, you are now right back where you started, and you’ve cost yourself quite a bit of time and frustration.
Compare that unhappy situation to this one: You leave your “A” page unchanged. On your “B” page, you only change the headline. Your conversion rate stays essentially the same. You leave that page unchanged and change the call to action text on the B page. Great news! Your conversion rate increases. So you add that change to your A page which is now more optimized than before.
So many in the online marketing world who do A/B testing in their enthusiasm “jump in with both feet” and try to make too many changes all at once on the B page. This is a mistake. It’s a mistake that will keep you from getting anywhere near the results you want.
Even though you want to only change and split test one landing page element at a time, don’t limit yourself when you are choosing which elements to test. You can test almost anything. You might be pleasantly surprised at the improvements you can experience from testing not just large scale elements like copy and graphics but also “lesser” page elements like call to action button placement and colors.
Keep reading for a real life landing page A/B testing success story where a seemingly minor change led to huge conversion rate improvements.
Don’t run your A/B test for too short a time period or for too long either. If you test for too short a time period, your results may be a statistical anomaly and may not accurately tell you the change that needs to be made to improve your results. Test too long and you won’t begin implementing changes soon enough and you’ll delay the improvement you are looking for.
So what landing page elements can you test? The sky’s the limit, but here’s a list to give you some ideas:
- • Headlines
- • Sub-headlines
- • Copy and content, including testimonials and image captions
- • Graphics and images, including font types and sizes and color schemes
- • Call to action buttons – placement, color, text, etc.
A Word Of Caution
When you are conducting an A/B test on your landing page, your goal is to improve something, with the ultimate goal of enjoying a higher conversion rate. Be aware that not every test you run will yield the improvement you want. Some will show little or no change, and some will show a worse result.
Don’t fret over this, it’s normal. It’s even desirable, in a way. Think about it: knowing what doesn’t work can be just as useful as knowing what does and can go a long way toward helping you reach your ultimate conversion goals.
Two Real Life Landing Page A/B Testing Success Stories
This article gives an example of a landing page A/B testing success story. And it drives home the point that no detail of a landing page is too small or insignificant to test. Even seemingly “minor” changes can lead to a higher conversion rate – i.e. – more sales for you!
In this graphic from the article, you’ll notice the different colors of the “Search Homes” call to action button. A click on the button equals a conversion. In this test, version A was the control, the “A” in the A/B test. Version “D” was the “B” in the A/B test. In version D, the button color was changed to blue; this increased conversions (clicks) by 17%!
Here’s another real life A/B testing success story. The Guardian, a news website from the UK has an online dating subscription service called Soulmates. The Soulmates landing page was experiencing a high traffic flow, but the conversion rate was much lower than desired, because the landing page was confusing to visitors who perceived incorrectly that their choice of members’ profiles to browse would be limited.
Notice that the first landing page image shows only one profile with a button that says “Join now for free”. It’s understandable that this page could limit paid registrations, don’t you agree?
In the A/B test that was run, this page was left as the control “A” page.
On the “B” page, the call to action button to “sell” direct signups was removed. This page sought to make it clear to users that they had many profiles available to view when searching. An easily accessible and simple to use search form was added.
Whereas the “A” page showed only one member’s headshot, giving the impression of a severely limited number of profiles to browse, the “B” page added additional headshots (greyed out in the image below). A benefit-oriented headline – “…find great dates…” was also added.
Compare the first landing page which gave many visitors the distinct impression that their search options were very limited to the second page that gave them the impression there were a lot more profiles they could search and contact.
The result of this A/B test? The B page showed a vast improvement – conversions improved by 46%!
The Bottom Line
So what’s the bottom line? A/B testing works! You can use it to launch your online marketing results into the stratosphere. You can, with A/B testing, continuously optimize your landing page’s conversion rates.
A Marketer’s Guide to Working Smarter Not Harder
The 4-1-1 on 4 Real-Time Personalization Myths
Real-time personalization: is it just the latest in a long line of industry buzzwords? Or, is it an accepted best practice that can propel...
Why Wait? 4 Ways to Make an Instant Impact in Your New Marketing Role
In a time where everything is changing, many marketers have reevaluated their careers and are taking on new roles in 2021. And whether it’s...